PWC audit confirms Sanusi's allegation, NNPC deducted $18.53bn oil revenue

PWC audit confirms Sanusi's allegation, NNPC deducted $18.53bn oil revenue

Monday, April 27, 2015 11:59 pm


A forensic audit of Nigeria’s state oil firm released on Monday confirmed the accusation by Emir Muhammed Sanusi that the NNPC withheld about $20 billion that it ought to have remitted to the national treasury.

The report ordered released by President Goodluck Jonathan, more than two months after it was submitted by PriceWaterHouseCoopers confirmed that the NNPC illegally expended $18.53 billion on operational costs, kerosene and petrol subsidies, without authorisation from the National Assembly. Part of the money was also withheld by an NNPC subsidiary, without National Assembly authorisation.

Although the audit found that the firm overpaid the state by almost $750 million, within the 19 months probed, it recommended a refund of $1.5 billion to government coffers. The audit covered January 2012 to July 2013.

Outgoing Nigerian President Goodluck Jonathan released the audit days after his elected replacement, Muhammadu Buhari, pledged to probe the allegation all over again and crack down on corruption in the energy company once in office.

The probe of Nigeria National Petroleum Corporation’s (NNPC) books was instituted last year after former central bank governor Lamido Sanusi said the firm had withheld $20 billion in oil revenue from government coffers, jeopardising the country’s finances.

Sanusi had told a Senate committee in 2014 that NNPC had received $67 billion and handed over only $47 billion.

After the allegations, Jonathan publicly dismissed the claim and replaced Sanusi, saying the banker had mismanaged the central bank’s budget. Sanusi has since become Emir of Kano, the country’s second-highest Islamic authority.

The PwC audit, however, said NNPC and its upstream subsidiary, the Nigerian Petroleum Development Company, should hand over $1.48 billion arising from unsubstantiated costs, duplicated subsidy claims and computation errors.

The report also recommended an overhaul of how NNPC is run.

“The NNPC model of operation must be urgently reviewed and restructured, as the current model which has been in operation since the creation of the corporation cannot be sustained,” it said in the 200-page document.

An earlier one-page version of the report, which had been due out in September, was released in February.

The affair has caused consternation in a nation long accustomed to reports of grand graft in Africa’s largest oil producer.

Analysts say Buhari, 72, managed to oust Jonathan in elections last month because voters believed he would tackle graft in Africa’s largest economy.

*From Reuters report


Join The Conversation

4 Comments

  • bayuse says:

    In addition, the issue that the incoming government will need to resolve would be whether all those big, illegal expenditures were actually made.

  • bayuse says:

    You have to be pitied as well. You are exploiting the licentiousness of the internet to disparage organisations. What did Lamido allege? That oil money was not remitted, starting with $49b. Then he pruned it to $20 billion. There came the justification that the money allegedly missing had been spent, on the authorisation of Diezani, instead of the authorisation of the National Assembly which has the power of appropriation. Sanusi contended that subsidy on kerosene was stopped by Yar’Adua in 2009, yet Diezani claimed to have spent billions in 2012/2013. Calculate the amount spent illegally by the oil minister and add up the $1.5 billion PWC says the NNPC should refund, then you begin to see the $20 billion picture emerging. What I suspect was done in this story is sheer interpretation, part of the liberty of the news media.

  • Frank says:

    Its a pity online publications like yours are allowed to operate without any regulation. The report did not confirm what your headline appears to be alluding to. In fact it categorically says $20bn was not missing but rather $1.4bn had not been remitted. Why do you thrive on sensationalism rather than true journalism?. You guys are frauds and a big disgrace.

  • Chuck Ghainard says:

    Even on face value, Emir Sanusi appears like an honorable man . I watched his interview with Amanpour on CNN. If Emir Sanusi says $20 B is missing, it is what he says until proven otherwise. Unlike the majority of Nigeria’s so called Leadership including Obasanjo, Emir Sanusi is a man of integrity. Buhari will come off the gates smoldering and cement his reputation if he probes NNPC, retrieves every stolen dollar and sticks the culprits where they belong

  • What do you think?

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.